« Ind. Courts - "Chiropractor, attorney accused of scam: Accident victim says her saga painful; federal case alleges insurance fraud" | Main | Ind. Gov't - "If there is a default of some kind or a bankruptcy, can Indiana get the toll road back and lease it again?" »

Sunday, August 09, 2009

Ind. Law - "Tough abuse law makes detectives of animal officers"

Michael Zennie's reports today in the Fort Wayne Journal Gazette on the impact of new animal cruelty laws and ordinances. Some quotes:

This spring, [Christopher Meihls, a Fort Wayne police crime scene technician] and other Fort Wayne police officers helped provide every Animal Care and Control officer with instruction in the art and science of criminal investigation.

The initial impetus for the training came in 2007 when the legislature created the crime of domestic violence animal cruelty. Because of that law, killing a pet or other animal to intimidate or terrorize a family member or partner became a felony, punishable by up to three years in prison.

“One of the best ways to control people is to control the things they love,” Allen County Prosecutor Karen Richards said.

The training armed each officer with a detective’s mind-set and the skills of a crime scene investigator. They learned skills such as how to handle evidence so it will hold up in court and recognizing evidence of a suspect’s probable guilt.

The training has led to one felony arrest – of a man accused of mutilating a dachshund – and the promise of many more investigations like it, Animal Care and Control Director Belinda Lewis said. * * *

Aside from the new statute, numerous other animal-related crimes carry possible prison time, including torturing or mutilating an animal and promoting or engaging in dogfighting.
The training

But with the steeply increased penalties for domestic violence animal cruelty comes a vastly increased burden to prove that the suspect committed the crime.

Animal Care and Control officers have to adhere to the same standards in proving a case as any police officer. They must be certain they obtained evidence through lawful searches; that any information from suspects comes after they are read their constitutional rights; and that the crime scene is accurately documented and stays uncontaminated.

So when Lewis developed the training for her officers, she drew on the training she received from experts in veterinary forensics at the University of Florida and other leaders in the field.

But for hands-on experience, Lewis turned to the local experts in human criminal investigation – the Fort Wayne Police Department.

Meihls, also a Fort Wayne police patrolman, said the Animal Care and Control officers were familiar with many of the concepts of criminal investigations from their day-to-day work. But the training reinforced the elements of building a solid case and gave them guidelines, he said.

The four-day, 32-hour hands-on course covered a dozen major points, nearly every aspect of criminal investigation.

Officers were trained on the proper way to handle evidence – making sure the crime scene is taped off and locked down so the public cannot accidentally destroy evidence, and ensuring evidence is labeled and secured so that its validity cannot be contested in court.

This, in particular, is a major new development, said officer Randy Thornton, a four-year veteran of animal control. Before, officers were less thorough when they collected evidence from an animal cruelty case – sometimes throwing it into any empty filing cabinet drawer, he said.

Now, for any evidence, officers bag it and tag it, fill out a form showing the chain of custody, and secure it in a locked evidence locker.

Lewis’ training course spent the most time on diagramming and photographing crime scenes. The goal is to document every relevant piece of evidence in enough detail that the scene can be easily re-created, Lewis said.

Every step of the training was supplemented with hands-on experience. This culminated in a series of mock crime scenes that re-created actual neglect and abuse cases.

The exercise included animals that had previously been euthanized. Their carcasses were shot, stabbed and hung to show the officers what real wounds look like.

Posted by Marcia Oddi on August 9, 2009 09:15 AM
Posted to Indiana Law