« Courts - "On aliens, Arizona may win — for now" | Main | Ind. Law - "Indiana Republicans seeks to enact abortion restrictions: Governor had wanted to focus on fiscal, not social issues" »

Thursday, December 09, 2010

Ind. Law - "Sharia law not an issue in Indiana — or any other state"

From an editorial today in the Terre Haute Tribune-Star that begins:

The Indiana legislature faces a full plate of important issues in its upcoming 2011 session. The far-fetched fear of Sharia law — a strict interpretation of Muslim law — overriding the U.S. or state constitution in Indiana courts is not one of those crucial issues. It’s not even worthy of backburner status, especially amid education funding and reform proposals, jobs creation, local government restructuring and ethics, and health care.

Last week, Rep. Bruce Borders, a Jasonville Republican, said he intended to file a bill in the Indiana House to prevent the recognition of Sharia law in Indiana courts. Borders said he was acting on an idea by state Sen. John Waterman, R-Shelburn.

The bill, Borders said, would proclaim “that Indiana does not recognize Sharia law, or Muslim law. What that boils down to is there is a push in some states to recognize Sharia law with its own court system, as opposed to a state constitution or the U.S. Constitution.”

The problem is, this isn’t a problem. It’s not a problem in Indiana. It’s not a problem anywhere in the United States, including Oklahoma, the state that apparently sparked Waterman’s interest. Last month, Oklahomans overwhelmingly approved an amendment to their constitution to prohibit state courts from considering international law or Islamic law when deciding cases.

The editorial ends:
The one unmistakable reality in this situation is that religious freedom is clearly protected under the Constitution. Muslims should not be singled out. The paranoid political atmosphere helped drive the Oklahoma vote, with the amendment getting 70-percent approval. Indiana lawmakers should not get swept up in such a needless venture. Incoming House Speaker Brian Bosma, R-Indianapolis, wisely imposed a 10-bill limit on House members to keep them focused on balancing the budget when the General Assembly gathers on Jan. 5. Borders’ bill would be nothing more than a distraction from that.

Posted by Marcia Oddi on December 9, 2010 09:49 AM
Posted to Indiana Law