« Ind. Courts - "When Judge Fran Gull recently took a 19-year-old drunk driver’s guilty plea, she asked the teen whether she knew her plea could affect her immigration status" | Main | Ind. Gov't. - More on: General Assembly mistakenly repeals FSSA, effective June 30, 2011 »

Sunday, July 10, 2011

Ind. Gov't. - What happens when a legislator want to introduce a questionable, or blatantly unconstitutional, law?

When I worked at the Statehouse many years ago, in jobs such as head of the public law division of the LSA, and as chief counsel to the Indiana senate, the rule was -- advise the legislator of the legal issues raised by his proposal, suggest workarounds if there were any. But ultimately, the question of whether to proceed was up to the legislator. The practice seems to be the same today.

As Tom LoBianco of the AP reports today, in a story headed "Legislative safeguards can't keep Indiana from court when contentious laws win approval":

INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — Indiana conservatives appeared to win major national victories with a trio of laws passed this year cracking down on illegal immigration, defunding abortion clinics and paying for children to attend private schools.

But rebukes from a pair of federal judges and a lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of the state's sweeping new school voucher law have raised questions about how proposed laws are vetted for legal issues before they get to a vote in the General Assembly.

Lawmakers ultimately decide how Indiana handles hot-button issues, but legislative staff try to raise red flags about clear constitutional violations or other possible missteps along the way, said Jeff Papa, chief of staff to Senate President Pro Tem David Long.

"It's not a hard science," he said.

A pair of federal judges placed temporary holds last month on two key victories for Republicans who control the General Assembly: a plan to block funds to Planned Parenthood of Indiana and portions of a new law that would have broadened police officers' ability to arrest illegal immigrants and blocked the use of foreign identification cards.

In granting a temporary injunction blocking part of the state's new immigration law, U.S. District Judge Sarah Evans Barker said the state's efforts "have proven to be seriously flawed and generally unsuccessful."

The Indiana State Teachers Association filed the most recent challenge to a state law at the start of the month, saying the plan to pay for students to attend private schools violates a clause in the state constitution mandating the state provide a "general and uniform System of Common Schools."

The story quotes blogger Doug Masson, who:
... used to work for Indiana's Legislative Services Agency, which does the grunt work of translating lawmakers' ideas and goals into legislation. LSA lawyers typically alert lawmakers if they spot something that is either unconstitutional or would violate federal law, he said.

Their job, Masson said, is not to make political judgments of whether an idea is good or bad, but to give lawmakers the lay of the land and let them decide whether to proceed from there.

In the past, moderate Republican leaders like Bob Garton, who used to head the Indiana Senate, would often keep hot-button issues like abortion locked away in committees, rather than put lawmakers through a grueling debate or get the state locked up in court, he said. * * *

Both parties in the Indiana House and Senate maintain their own legal counsel, who guide lawmakers on legal questions and often provide spot answers during contentious debates.

Working in conjunction with the LSA lawyers, the Republican and Democratic advisers try their best to catch obvious mistakes or possible pratfalls, Papa said.

But in the end, whether to pass a law is a political decision made collectively by the state's lawmakers, Papa said.

"They could ask for anything in the world to be drafted, whether it's a good idea, a constitutional idea, or a bad idea," he said. "Then it's up to the political process where you go from there."

Posted by Marcia Oddi on July 10, 2011 12:10 PM
Posted to Indiana Government