« Law - "Michigan Governor Vetoes Gun Bill" | Main | Environment - Still more on: Concerns in NW Indiana about Enbridge Energy Partners LP's aging Line 6B oil pipeline and its replacement »

Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Ind. Decisions - "Judge OKs sale of 2 vacant public schools"

For background, start with this Nov. 3, 2012 ILB entry headed "EACS sues to clear up confusion on sale law: Charters get 1st buy chance."

Rebecca S. Green reports today in the Fort Wayne Journal Gazette:

FORT WAYNE – An Allen Superior Court judge ruled two local public school districts can sell two vacant schools without letting the buildings languish for four years in case a future charter school wants to use them.

The ruling came Tuesday in two cases involving the Indiana Public Charter Schools Association and Fort Wayne Community Schools and East Allen County Schools.

In the case involving the Fort Wayne school district, the charter school association sued to stop the sale of the Pleasant Center Elementary School building to the Fort Wayne-Allen County Airport Authority. It was an agreement reached before the changes to the charter school law went into effect, but was about to be made official by an airport board vote the day the association filed its lawsuit.

In the East Allen case, the district sued the charter school association to get a judge to weigh in on whether the district should be allowed to sell the shuttered Monroeville Elementary School to the Fort Wayne-South Bend Catholic Diocese, which wanted to use it for educational purposes. Because the diocese has offered to buy the building, no existing charter school has expressed any interest in its use. * * *

At issue was whether amendments to the Indiana law governing the sale of abandoned school buildings mean that vacant classroom buildings have to sit on a waiting list for four years providing charter schools the opportunity to claim them for $1, or whether the districts can sell the buildings under long-held state laws if no existing charter school is asking for them at the time of the sale.

Attorneys for both districts argued that a plain reading of the statute said that the buildings go on the Department of Education list until another offer comes up or until a charter school expresses interest in buying or leasing it for $1.

Attorneys for the Indiana Public Charter Schools Association argued that a district cannot sell or dispose of a building until it sits on the list for four years, unclaimed by an interested charter school. But even if no charter expresses interest, the building must remain on the list.

In her 12-page ruling, Allen Superior Court Judge Nancy Boyer found in favor of the school districts. She said state law does not prohibit the districts from selling or transferring buildings to entities that want them.

She wrote that those amendments to the law, enacted in 2011 as part of a sweeping charter schools bill, did not modify or repeal the existing wording of state law and did not limit the school districts’ ability to transfer its own property.

“Reading (state law) to require a school corporation to refuse to sell or transfer unneeded property to a purchaser … forces a school corporation to bear the costs associated with maintaining an unneeded and unoccupied building for an unreasonably long period of time,” she wrote.

The 48-month time frame is not triggered unless a charter school files a letter of intent expressing interest in the building, Boyer wrote.

“(The) Charter Schools’ interpretation fails to protect taxpayer investment in school assets,” Boyer wrote. “Forcing unused school properties to sit idle for four years, even if no charter school is interested, is contrary to the public interest.”

Posted by Marcia Oddi on December 19, 2012 09:30 AM
Posted to Ind. Trial Ct. Decisions