« Law - "Law Schools’ Applications Fall as Costs Rise and Jobs Are Cut" | Main | Ind. Courts - Who will fill Lake County Judge Bonaventura's juvenile court vacancy? »

Thursday, January 31, 2013

Ind. Decisions - COA decision in Brewington engenders national interest

UCLA Law Prof Eugene Volokh of The Volokh Conspiracy has just posted again on the Jan. 17th Ind. COA opinion in Brewington v. State. Here is his Jan. 22nd post.

The ILB has had a number of posts on this opinion, including this one from Jan. 21, 2013.

From today's Volokh post:

I blogged last week about Brewington v. State (Ind. Ct. App. Jan. 17, 2013), a decision that strikes me as unconstitutional, and as quite perilous for Indiana speakers: It basically concludes that harshly and repeatedly criticizing someone — in that case, a judge, but the law applies equally to legislators, other government officials, business leaders, and others — for that person’s past conduct can be criminally prosecuted. * * *

This, I think, clearly violates the First Amendment, and has a potentially very broad sweep. The law doesn’t just apply to disgruntled litigants, but also to newspaper columnists, advocacy groups, politicians, and so on. Under the court’s view, someone who goes to a legislator and says, “If you vote for this law [or because you voted for this law], we’re going to condemn you so much that your constituents will have contempt for you and vote you out of office,” would be guilty of a crime. Indeed, someone who simply keeps writing harshly critical columns about a legislator’s actions, without an overt threat of future such columns, would be guilty of a crime, too.

Brewington is asking the Indiana Supreme Court to review the case, and I think it would be helpful to have a friend-of-the-court brief supporting that request, and alerting the Indiana Supreme Court to the broader danger posed by the Indiana Court of Appeals opinion. (The Indiana Supreme Court is entitled to pick and choose which Court of Appeals cases it reviews, so the brief needs to persuade the Indiana Supreme Court to focus its time on attention on this case.) I plan to write that brief, pro bono.

I already have local counsel lined up, and a likely amicus organization, but I’d like to have more, including those generally seen as on the left, those generally seen as on the right, and those generally seen as elsewhere. If you’re involved with an Indiana advocacy, political, or journalist group — or for that matter an Indiana newspaper, whether professional or student-run — and you think the organization might be interested in joining, please let me know.

Posted by Marcia Oddi on January 31, 2013 03:56 PM
Posted to Ind. App.Ct. Decisions