« Ind. Courts - More on: David Camm trial in Lebanon, which began August 22, continues into another week | Main | Ind. Courts - Brewington blogger/first amendment case to be argued at 9 am tomorrow before Supreme Court »

Wednesday, September 11, 2013

Ind. Courts - Two articles by Alison Frankel on the 7th Circuit and class actions

Just posted, re yesterday's 7th Circuit opinion in Hughes v. Kore of Indiana, Alison Frankel writes in a long post for her Reuters blog that begins:

Reading opinions by Judge Richard Posner of the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals is like jumping waves in a calm ocean. You bob along in the buoyancy of Posner’s ideas until you turn around to face shore and wonder how you drifted so far from where you started. So it is in an 11-page ruling Tuesday, addressing whether a class of ATM users may be certified to seek statutory damages under the Electronic Funds Transfer Act for a tiny defendant’s failure to post stickers notifying users of ATM fees. As you know, these are more turbulent waters than they first appear, roiled by uncertainty about constitutional standing and appropriate classwide relief. Posner’s prose nevertheless carries you along so forcefully that you don’t even notice until you’re done that he has deposited you in a land where all the rules are Posner-made.

Okay, I’m exaggerating. But once again, the iconoclastic appellate judge has issued an important opinion on consumer class actions that reflects his vision, as an economic rationalist, of the potential efficiencies of resolving hundreds or thousands of individual claims with a single proceeding. He did it last month when, on remand from the U.S. Supreme Court, he [Posner] and two 7th Circuit colleagues recertified a class of Sears washing-machine purchasers for the purposes of determining whether Sears is liable for a design that supposedly results in a moldy odor. Sears has called the ruling “judicial fiat.” In the new opinion, Posner and his fellow 7th Circuit panelists Daniel Manion and Diane Wood urge trial judges to use common sense in deciding whether to certify a consumer class seeking statutory damages, focusing on realistic solutions and not hypothetical problems.

Posted by Marcia Oddi on September 11, 2013 04:27 PM
Posted to Ind. (7th Cir.) Decisions