« Ind. Law - "The Indianapolis Bar Association and HJR-3" | Main | Ind. Decisions - Supreme Court issues opinion in Wabash College hazing case »

Thursday, February 13, 2014

Ind. Decisions - "Casino exemption costs Evansville smoking ban"

Niki Kelly of the Fort Wayne Journal Gazette reports today on Tuesday's Supreme Court combined opinion in the Evansville smoking ban challenges. Some quotes:

Evansville officials can’t spare a casino from the city’s smoking ban, the Indiana Supreme Court ruled Tuesday.

The justices voted 3-2 to throw out the part of the ban that prohibits smoking in taverns and private clubs but exempts the riverboat casino that’s docked at the Ohio River city.

Leaving the casino out of the ban violates the Indiana Constitution’s equal privileges and immunities clause, which prohibits giving any citizen or class of citizen privileges or immunities not extended to everyone, the justices said.

They reversed an appeals court ruling that upheld the ordinance.

Chief Justice Brent Dickson wrote that granting the casino an exemption was “tantamount to the government selling exemption ... for the bonus of anticipated financial benefits.”

But Justice Loretta Rush said those very benefits were part of what made the casino unique and entitled it to an exemption.

Rush wrote in her dissent that the casino had “inherent characteristics” that set it apart from other local businesses.

Among those were the fact that most of its customers come from out of town, and that including the riverboat in the ban could cost Evansville more than $4.3 million in lost tax revenue and $6.3 million in lost wages of casino employees. Justice Robert Rucker agreed. * * *

The ruling puts the city’s 2006 smoking ban back into effect. That ban prohibited smoking in workplaces and other public places but exempted bars, private clubs and riverboats.

It was an amendment in 2012 that extended the smoking ban to all businesses, including taverns and clubs, but still exempted the Tropicana Evansville casino.

Tavern owners and club officials challenged the ordinance, arguing that it treated their operations unfairly.

The Indiana Alcohol & Tobacco Commission [ILB: see news release] said establishments that are no longer prohibited from allowing smoking as a result of the ruling must still follow the state smoking law, which requires the posting of signs and filing for exemptions with the Indiana Excise Police.

Posted by Marcia Oddi on February 13, 2014 12:43 PM
Posted to Ind. Sup.Ct. Decisions