Tuesday, April 28, 2015
Ind. Gov't. - "Effort to withhold state legislative records stalls"
On April 15th the ILB posted "Lawsuit filed for certain House Republican caucus emails," which includes both the complaint and links to the Public Access Counselor opinions in the now pending case of CAC v. Ed Koch and Indiana House Republican Caucus.
This afternoon, two seasoned statehouse reporters, Tom LoBianco of the IndyStar, and Niki Kelly of the Fort Wayne Journal Gazette, have posted stories on a behind the scenes, now abandoned effort to rewrite the public records law to deny public access to legislative emails.
From the Star story:
A last-minute push to protect state lawmakers from having to disclose public records, including their emails and other documents, has stalled, but is likely to resurface next year.From the FWJG story:
Senate and House lawmakers had scheduled a conference committee for Tuesday morning to consider a measure that would have specifically exempted their exchanges from public disclosure. But the meeting was cancelled at the last minute Tuesday morning.
House Speaker Brian Bosma, whose lawyers are fighting off a challenge from a Washington-based environmental group, said the protection is needed, but will probably have to wait.
"Ultimately I thought it was inadvisable for us to put legislation together at the last second, despite the appropriateness of it and the need for it," he said Tuesday.
Lawmakers are a little more than 24 hours from wrapping up work on their 2015 legislative session. The issue of access to public records arose earlier in the session when the Energy and Policy Institute sought emails between House Energy Chairman Eric Koch, R-Bedford, and Duke Energy regarding solar energy legislation.
Bosma's staff flatly refused the request, citing a 1993 court case that allegedly exempted all state lawmakers from the state's public records laws. But Indiana's public access counselor, who is appointed by the governor to interpret state open records laws, determined at the time that lawmakers, along with other public agencies, are still subject to the law.
"It is the opinion of the public access counselor the Indiana General Assembly is subject to the Access to Public Records Act," Public Access Counselor Luke Britt wrote in the conclusion of his March 6 opinion.
But because the opinion's are only advisory, and not enforceable, Bosma's staff replied that they would still not release the emails. Specifically, Bosma's chief counsel, Jill Carnell, argued that a pair of Indiana Supreme Court cases left the decision solely up to the General Assembly, as to whether disclose.
A last-second attempt to conceal legislative records from the public hit a wall Tuesday morning.
A conference committee hearing had been called for Senate Bill 528 - a bill about public records. Legislative leaders were considering adding language to officially exempt legislative calls and emails.
The move is related to a recent lawsuit filed against the Indiana House, and multiple opinions by the Indiana Public Access Counselor that the General Assembly must follow the state public records law.
But the Tuesday meeting was scrapped.
"Ultimately I thought it was inadvisable to put legislation together at the last second despite the appropriateness of it and the need for it," said Republican House Speaker Brian Bosma. "Probably best not to do it."
Citizens Action Coalition, Common Cause Indiana and the Energy and Policy Institute filed a lawsuit earlier this month in Marion County against the Indiana House Republican Caucus and State Rep. Eric Koch, R-Bedford, for violating the Indiana Access to Public Records Act.
According to a press release, the groups are asking the court to declare that Koch and the caucus are subject to the state open records law, which the GOP legislators have denied, and to order disclosure of correspondence between Rep. Koch and utility companies regarding solar energy issues.